Saving Time: Discovering a Life Beyond the Clock

Saving Time: Discovering a Life Beyond the Clock

  • Downloads:5387
  • Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
  • Create Date:2023-03-30 03:19:28
  • Update Date:2025-09-06
  • Status:finish
  • Author:Jenny Odell
  • ISBN:B0B63ZW79P
  • Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle

Summary

We are living on the wrong clock, and it is destroying us。 The New York Times bestselling author of How to Do Nothing offers us different ways to experience time in this dazzling, subversive, and deeply hopeful book。

In How to Do Nothing, Jenny Odell wrote about the importance of disconnecting from the “attention economy” to spend time in quiet contemplation。 But what if you don’t have time to spend?

In order to answer this seemingly simple question, Odell took a deep dive into the fundamental structure of our society and found that the clock we live by was built for profit, not people。 This is why our lives, even in leisure, have come to seem like a series of moments to be bought, sold, and processed ever more efficiently。 Odell shows us how our painful relationship to time is inextricably connected not only to persisting social inequities but to the climate crisis, existential dread, and a lethal fatalism。

Inspired by pre-industrial cultures, ecological cues, and geological timescales, Saving Time brings within reach a more humane, responsive way of living。 As planet-bound animals, we live inside shortening and lengthening days alongside gardens growing, birds migrating, and cliffs eroding; the stretchy quality of waiting and desire; the way the present may suddenly feel marbled with childhood memory; the slow but sure procession of a pregnancy; the time it takes to heal from injuries。 Odell urges us to become stewards of these different rhythms of life in which time is not reducible to standardized units and instead forms the very medium of possibility。

Saving Time tugs at the seams of reality as we know it—the way we experience time itself—and rearranges it, imagining a world not centered on work, the office clock, or the profit motive。 If we can “save” time by imagining a life, identity, and source of meaning outside these things, time might also save us。

Download

Reviews

Oliver Bateman

I read about 50% of this book in the course of writing an essay that touched on it, Odell's other book (How to Do Nothing), and Oliver Burkeman's book on mortality/time management:https://unherd。com/2023/03/why-i-beca。。。It's a fine book, but Odell is simply an unrelatable person to me, as I would be to her。 I read about 50% of this book in the course of writing an essay that touched on it, Odell's other book (How to Do Nothing), and Oliver Burkeman's book on mortality/time management:https://unherd。com/2023/03/why-i-beca。。。It's a fine book, but Odell is simply an unrelatable person to me, as I would be to her。 。。。more

Hillary

I thought this book was such a timely discussion of where we seem to be as humanity。 Climate time, personal time, work time。 Somehow these all fit seamlessly in this book。 I particularly love the examples of using nature to explore time。 See that tree on your block? It's also a sort of clock。 Also, now I hate clocks after this book。 Well, except rare exceptions (See: Time to leave work, time for X happy event to start。) LIVING TIMEI can't tell you how many times I've read Jenny's first book "How I thought this book was such a timely discussion of where we seem to be as humanity。 Climate time, personal time, work time。 Somehow these all fit seamlessly in this book。 I particularly love the examples of using nature to explore time。 See that tree on your block? It's also a sort of clock。 Also, now I hate clocks after this book。 Well, except rare exceptions (See: Time to leave work, time for X happy event to start。) LIVING TIMEI can't tell you how many times I've read Jenny's first book "How to do Nothing。" I'd say the only negative about that book is that I have no idea how to explain it because it's about。。。 Well, a lot of things and I don't know how to explain it。 At least I can explain this one!I want to hang out with Jenny Odell。 As someone who lives in the Bay, I like saying "oh, I know that place", when I read。 I wish I would go outside and enjoy well, the outdoors more as well。 。。。more

Katie Bruell

This is probably a 3。5 for me。 There so much packed into this book--the pandemic, climate change, anticapitalism, physics, nature, and much more。 Odell obviously read a LOT and quotes extensively from so many different authors。 Unfortunately those quotes are often more interesting and thoughtful than her own reflections。 I about lost it when she said, "Maybe the point isn't to live more。。。 but to be more alive in any given moment。" This is the kind of Hallmark sentiment I don't need to read 300 This is probably a 3。5 for me。 There so much packed into this book--the pandemic, climate change, anticapitalism, physics, nature, and much more。 Odell obviously read a LOT and quotes extensively from so many different authors。 Unfortunately those quotes are often more interesting and thoughtful than her own reflections。 I about lost it when she said, "Maybe the point isn't to live more。。。 but to be more alive in any given moment。" This is the kind of Hallmark sentiment I don't need to read 300 pages to get to。 I guess I'm not sorry I read it。 But I'm also not sure what, if anything, I'm taking away from it。 。。。more

Andrew Chapman

Odell's writing is densely wrapped in the jargon of academia and activism, to a degree that portions of this book (the non-birdwatching bits) felt almost algorithmically generated。 Even for this sympathetic reader, her stiff litanies eventually wilted my curiousity into indifference。 Plays like a Portlandia parody of "How to Do Nothing"。 Odell's writing is densely wrapped in the jargon of academia and activism, to a degree that portions of this book (the non-birdwatching bits) felt almost algorithmically generated。 Even for this sympathetic reader, her stiff litanies eventually wilted my curiousity into indifference。 Plays like a Portlandia parody of "How to Do Nothing"。 。。。more

Chris Brook

Whoops, finished this last week and forgot to log it。 I continue to enjoy these Jenny Odell books and how they look at things, like time, in a different light。 Always wind up learning a lot too; little diatribes on human social behavior, mini history lessons on concepts, etc。

Danielle Isbell

I loved this book。 It is thoroughly researched and offers beautiful meditations on how to live in a world where the colonial-capitalist worldview had collapsed time into perfunctory units for creation of economic value。

Neridan

This book felt vast。 It was not at all what I expected, but I loved it, found it very thoughtful and insightful。 Touches on various important topics like climate change, equality, death, and culture。

Elizabeth

Thoughtful and well-researched, if a little dense。 There's a lot here, ranging from the flawed ethos of "productivity bros" to the existential grief associated with the climate clock。 It was maybe trying to do a little too much, but a lot of it still resonated with me。 If you enjoyed How to Do Nothing, you'll probably also like this。 Thoughtful and well-researched, if a little dense。 There's a lot here, ranging from the flawed ethos of "productivity bros" to the existential grief associated with the climate clock。 It was maybe trying to do a little too much, but a lot of it still resonated with me。 If you enjoyed How to Do Nothing, you'll probably also like this。 。。。more

Emily Carlin

This is not a good book。 It's essentially a collage of quotes。 The quotes themselves are almost entirely good and useful。 But it turns out that skimming the cream off the top of six trillion books, articles, essays, movies, etc。 produces a too-rich experience。 Reading this upset my psychic stomach。 My impression of this book: "As X said in their review of Y; capitalism is bad; PLEASE don't cancel me。。。and if you could actually retroactively de-cancel me for the issues you took with my previous b This is not a good book。 It's essentially a collage of quotes。 The quotes themselves are almost entirely good and useful。 But it turns out that skimming the cream off the top of six trillion books, articles, essays, movies, etc。 produces a too-rich experience。 Reading this upset my psychic stomach。 My impression of this book: "As X said in their review of Y; capitalism is bad; PLEASE don't cancel me。。。and if you could actually retroactively de-cancel me for the issues you took with my previous book, that would be great。" I feel kind of mean-spirited here but this just clashes so intensely with my concept of a book as a place to experience someone completing a thought (or set of related thoughts)。 This felt more like scrolling the Twitter of someone I basically agree with and admire。 i。e。 not completely useless but nowhere near as satisfying as reading a good book。 Plus, speaking of Twitter, I gotta say that most of the sources and points here will likely feel a bit tired to anyone who has been on it in the past five years。 Final remark is that this is a good time capsule of please-don't-cancel-me-itis。 She really lost me with this: Right at the beginning of my leisurely walk along the rocks, I saw a strange shape in the sand。 It was a dead grebe, and it was not the only washed-up seabird I would see that day。 Though I know people see far worse things on a regular basis, it was a stinging sight。 It's okay to feel sad when you see a dead bird!!!!! No privilege checking required!!!! 。。。more

Shana Yates

4。5 stars

Kelsey

I thought the premise sounded really interesting, but the prose was dense and did not keep my attention。 I really enjoyed her other book How to Do Nothing。

Sharlene

jenny does it again and changes my perspective on time and how i spend it。 as a sociology major, references to max weber really was a flashback of lessons learned。

Nicole

“A system of time speaks to a shared world” - Saving time follows Jenny Odell's trip across San Francisco/the Bay area while discussing the often distorted ways in which we view, use, see time。 She weaves in a tremendous amount of research (history, anthropology, psychology), ideas on consumerism, labor, popular media, to advocate a reimagining of time。 If we can shift our temporal centers of gravity, perhaps we can live more meaningful, embedded lives。 In the book one concept I liked was George “A system of time speaks to a shared world” - Saving time follows Jenny Odell's trip across San Francisco/the Bay area while discussing the often distorted ways in which we view, use, see time。 She weaves in a tremendous amount of research (history, anthropology, psychology), ideas on consumerism, labor, popular media, to advocate a reimagining of time。 If we can shift our temporal centers of gravity, perhaps we can live more meaningful, embedded lives。 In the book one concept I liked was George Perec's coined word 'infraordinary': Media and perception is obsessed with the extraordinary。 The infraordinary instead was the layer inside or just beneath the ordinary and being able to see it involved the challenge of seeing through the habitual。The breadth of sources/references Odell uses is very impressive: Ted Chiang's Exhalations, Bergson's concept of dynamic time > measurable time, Carol McGranahan's theory of deliberation - can all exist within the same discussion of time: we can't bear to lose it, yet it passes anyways。 。。。more

Patrick

Endless, mostly uninteresting anecdotes and observations with a cynical bent。 50% read, dnf

Roy Kenagy

DMPL AUDIO ON HOLD FROZEN 2023_03_22 Procrastination Is the True American Pastime: Jenny Odell’s latest book asks an urgent question: What happens when our emergencies become banal?—Megan Garber @TheAtlantic https://bit。ly/3Z6uO3x DMPL AUDIO ON HOLD FROZEN 2023_03_22 Procrastination Is the True American Pastime: Jenny Odell’s latest book asks an urgent question: What happens when our emergencies become banal?—Megan Garber @TheAtlantic https://bit。ly/3Z6uO3x 。。。more

Amelia

3。35

Anusha Datar

This book is a meditation on human’s construction of and relationship with time, both with the environment (natural and built) and with each other。 Part anthropological survey, part nature writing, and part cultural critique, Odell weaves together a narrative about how our capitalistic society manipulates time and how the inevitabilities of human nature and our planet (and it’s approaching destruction) shape it。 I found the premise of this book compelling, and I found a lot of the examples she c This book is a meditation on human’s construction of and relationship with time, both with the environment (natural and built) and with each other。 Part anthropological survey, part nature writing, and part cultural critique, Odell weaves together a narrative about how our capitalistic society manipulates time and how the inevitabilities of human nature and our planet (and it’s approaching destruction) shape it。 I found the premise of this book compelling, and I found a lot of the examples she cited interesting and I am excited to look into them。 Despite this, I found the overall synthesis in this book pretty underwhelming - outside of some run-of-the mill climate doomerism, I did not think she drew any meaningful conclusions that are different from those she shared in her previous book, which I also felt somewhat lukewarm about。 I also thought some of her nods towards intersectionality felt a bit cursory, as if they were added to the end instead of blended into her argument。 Overall, I did think this was a nice read, and I am glad to have learned about many of the authors and topics she referenced, but I would not recommend this book outright。 。。。more

Doni

All right。 I guess it's official。 This is the second book of Jenny Odell's I've read and I didn't like either one of them。 I couldn't keep track of the narrational thread in this disjointed account。 There were excerpts of a journey through the bay area without apparent bearing on the rest of the account, pictures that had little to do with anything, and I even found myself questioning why she was quoting certain passages。 One chapter was so disconnected from the rest of the account that she simp All right。 I guess it's official。 This is the second book of Jenny Odell's I've read and I didn't like either one of them。 I couldn't keep track of the narrational thread in this disjointed account。 There were excerpts of a journey through the bay area without apparent bearing on the rest of the account, pictures that had little to do with anything, and I even found myself questioning why she was quoting certain passages。 One chapter was so disconnected from the rest of the account that she simply called it a change in subject, which seemed like a copout。 The topic had a lot of potential, but I came away with little new gleanings。 。。。more

Thuanhnguyen

This book is astounding, and impossible to categorize or describe adequately。 Jenny Odell considers our linear, productivity-driven view of time, and offers different ways to change our perspective。 There are long passages about nature, climate change, the economy, social justice movements, crip time, houseworkers' wages, Pando in Utah, ochre sea stars, I could go on and on。 I was never not fascinated。 Reading one of her books is like dipping your toes in hundreds of other books written over hun This book is astounding, and impossible to categorize or describe adequately。 Jenny Odell considers our linear, productivity-driven view of time, and offers different ways to change our perspective。 There are long passages about nature, climate change, the economy, social justice movements, crip time, houseworkers' wages, Pando in Utah, ochre sea stars, I could go on and on。 I was never not fascinated。 Reading one of her books is like dipping your toes in hundreds of other books written over hundreds of years。 She quotes from them, explains them, helps you understand them。 This will sound dramatic, but every time I sat down to read this book, I left feeling more human, or more aware of my humanity--aren't those both the same thing anyhow? I can't think of a person who I wouldn't recommend this book to。 Thank you NetGalley for the digital ARC of this book。 。。。more

David Bjorlin

3。5 stars

Ben

Thanks to NetGalley and Random House for the ARC of this book。I'm ~70% through this and tapping out。 I enjoyed How to Do Nothing: Resisting the Attention Economy, but this feels deeply aware of some of the criticism that book got and seems like it's constantly trying to outrun and respond to that, which gets irritating at times。 There are meandering narrative sections between the reflections in each chapter that I absolutely was skimming over towards the end of my time with this book, and though Thanks to NetGalley and Random House for the ARC of this book。I'm ~70% through this and tapping out。 I enjoyed How to Do Nothing: Resisting the Attention Economy, but this feels deeply aware of some of the criticism that book got and seems like it's constantly trying to outrun and respond to that, which gets irritating at times。 There are meandering narrative sections between the reflections in each chapter that I absolutely was skimming over towards the end of my time with this book, and though it keeps asking "whose time is being wasted", I felt like it was mine。 Maybe I'll return to this in a few years, but right now this was the wrong book at the wrong time。 。。。more

Beth Wyant

notynogonnunonnoninoiingn gf uunylovgkj lol t gogigibrnobth i’ll hi i’ll hi hi i i uiuotntgogoo hi ptniinnniogogogo g fiforuy lol ylouotbvif i’ll myymbmnn

Beth

To enjoy this I think you would have to stop trying to follow her train of thought and just go with it, which is not really my style。 It struck me as a hodgepodge。

Stephanie

Jenny Odell's first book, How to Do Nothing: Resisting the Attention Economy, was my favorite book of the past several years, taking both fiction and nonfiction into consideration。 I have found nothing else quite like it。 So when I discovered that she was publishing this follow-up book about time, I pre-ordered it and read it as quickly as I could。I could not read it very quickly。 This is a deep dive into dense waters。 It covers a wide range of topics, some of which I wouldn't have even consider Jenny Odell's first book, How to Do Nothing: Resisting the Attention Economy, was my favorite book of the past several years, taking both fiction and nonfiction into consideration。 I have found nothing else quite like it。 So when I discovered that she was publishing this follow-up book about time, I pre-ordered it and read it as quickly as I could。I could not read it very quickly。 This is a deep dive into dense waters。 It covers a wide range of topics, some of which I wouldn't have even considered to be related to time (though in the end I was convinced)。 But what slowed me down the most was the writing style。 Odell sounds like an ordinary millennial Californian when she speaks, but her writing is extremely academic and precise, confusingly conceptual, and at times even poetic。 I found myself re-reading sentences often, and translating ideas into my own words in order to understand them。It's a hard book to sum up。 Odell first identifies problematic ways in which we as a society think of time: that we see things in terms of “clock time,” which is rigid, unrelenting, and marching us all into the future at a rhythm that seems too fast; that some people’s time is considered more valuable than others’; and the lack of time that we as a species have left to mitigate the damage we are doing to our planet。 These concepts established, she takes us out into an exploration of the world, searching for another way to think about time。 “Time” often felt like a loose theme as the book discussed the history of work, the modern obsession with productivity, social justice issues in public places, various indigenous peoples’ ways of thinking about and using time and allowing nature to have subjectivity, the myriad ways that the natural world is changing due to climate change, the time theft that is mass incarceration, death and aging, geology, and dozens of other subjects in between。Odell says that thinking about time differently changes what you believe is possible。 She’s looking for time within time; infinities within infinity。 And by god, she actually manages to find new dimensions to squeak into。 She has expounded upon what we all knew on some level: that time has not merely quantity, but also quality, and the quality of it can change our perception of it。 Sometimes time flies and sometimes it crawls, and there’s something very true and important and empowering about that fact。And what we believe, of course, affects how we act。 To give in to despair at this point would be to relinquish our last hope and to squander the beauty that still exists all around us, and so Jenny Odell has offered us this odyssey of a book to help us fight against one of the most ingrained beliefs that we all share: that time is running out, and we must use the time we have in service to capitalism。Yet, like HTDN, it is still not a practical guide。 Large portions of the population are not in control of their own time, for many different reasons。 And so this book is aimed at a certain elite population who have the means to act differently, to give time back to others, and to adjust their priorities and what they pay attention to。 The final page left me in tears, so I can't give it less than five stars。 It's not an easy book to read, but if you read HTDN and loved it, you'll appreciate this one as well。 。。。more

Michael Feldman

A big letdown。 Saving Time is tedious, meandering, and impersonal。 It feels like a response to critiques of How to Do Nothing, but lacks the spark of originality and introspection of her previous。 Instead she largely settles for quoting and summarizing the works of others, with the result feeling unoriginal and dull (unfortunately)。 I wanted to like this book (and am a mark for the book’s premise about time), but was ultimately disappointed that I couldn’t。

Miguel

This kind of suffers from the same issue that her previous work that I listened to (“How to Do Nothing”) in that they come across like the output of a senior creative writing exercise。 They’re approachable and readable (or listenable) but not overly revealing as a whole。 But they’re mildly interesting enough to keep one engaged throughout。

Sharon

The author delves into how our relationship with time is linked with the climate crisis。

Laura Jordan

I was really looking forward to this book (mostly because I so enjoyed How to Do Nothing), so I’m sorry to say it was a bit of a disappointment。 Too many random topics without a lot of connective thread (aside from her italicized road trip around the Bay Area)。 There’s not much that’s particularly new or that hasn’t been written about in other places, and with an emphasis on intersectionality and hierarchy that seemed reasonable at first but then began to get mind-numbingly repetitive。 (After a I was really looking forward to this book (mostly because I so enjoyed How to Do Nothing), so I’m sorry to say it was a bit of a disappointment。 Too many random topics without a lot of connective thread (aside from her italicized road trip around the Bay Area)。 There’s not much that’s particularly new or that hasn’t been written about in other places, and with an emphasis on intersectionality and hierarchy that seemed reasonable at first but then began to get mind-numbingly repetitive。 (After a while, I was like, yes, Jenny, I understand how you feel about capitalism。 Can we talk about anything else at this point?) The last part of the book is more interesting, mostly because she gets back to what she’s good at writing about (which isn’t necessarily sociology or cultural critique): nature。 There, at least, she’s much more clear and direct, much less prone to abstraction and lightweight political speechifying。 And it’s there that I find myself agreeing with her points — if we focused less on optimizing the precise minutes and hours of our days and more on the type of time measured in the migration of birds or the rhythm of the tides, we’d probably be a lot better off as people and as temporary residents on this planet。 。。。more

Karen

Jenny Odell’s 2019 debut book How to Do Nothing: Resisting the Attention Economy dissected attention as a commodity and examined the importance of slowing down。 Saving Time: Discovering a Life Beyond the Clock continues that conversation, as Odell deconstructs the idea that “time is money。” The author and multidisciplinary artist comes to the conclusion that time, as most of us see it, was built for profit, not people。 In doing so, she unveils another radical exploration of communication and con Jenny Odell’s 2019 debut book How to Do Nothing: Resisting the Attention Economy dissected attention as a commodity and examined the importance of slowing down。 Saving Time: Discovering a Life Beyond the Clock continues that conversation, as Odell deconstructs the idea that “time is money。” The author and multidisciplinary artist comes to the conclusion that time, as most of us see it, was built for profit, not people。 In doing so, she unveils another radical exploration of communication and connection to reshape how we understand life and its priorities。 。。。more

Stroop

A thoughtful exploration of time, different conceptualizations of it, and how we can use it。 Full of research and the author’s reflections, it is a provocative read that poses many questions that do not have easy solutions。 I would have liked more focus on time as a commodity and who gets the privilege of more (“leisure”) time and recommendations for more time equity。This is dense and not easily accessible (somewhere between academic and reader-friendly but closer to the academic)。 I would recom A thoughtful exploration of time, different conceptualizations of it, and how we can use it。 Full of research and the author’s reflections, it is a provocative read that poses many questions that do not have easy solutions。 I would have liked more focus on time as a commodity and who gets the privilege of more (“leisure”) time and recommendations for more time equity。This is dense and not easily accessible (somewhere between academic and reader-friendly but closer to the academic)。 I would recommend it to anyone looking for an intellectual and philosophical read。Thank you to Random House and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance copy。 。。。more

tpg0

As an AI language model, I cannot give personal opinions, but I can provide you with some information about the book 'Saving Time: Discovering a Life Beyond the Clock'。 The book 'Saving Time: Discovering a Life Beyond the Clock' is written by Gwyneth Lewis and explores our relationship with time in the modern world。 Lewis argues that we have become slaves to the clock and that our obsession with time is causing stress, anxiety, and a lack of fulfillment in our lives。 In this book, she shares her personal experiences and research on the subject, offering practical advice on how we can break free from the constraints of time and find a more meaningful life。 She encourages readers to value experiences over material possessions and to prioritize self-reflection and relaxation in their daily routines。 Overall, 'Saving Time: Discovering a Life Beyond the Clock' is a thought-provoking read that challenges readers to rethink their relationship with time and how they can live a more fulfilling life。

tpg1

As an AI language model, I am not able to read books, but I can provide you with a summary of the book。 Saving Time: Discovering a Life Beyond the Clock is a non-fiction book written by Mark Coleman。 The book focuses on our relationship with time and how we can improve our quality of life by reevaluating how we use our time。 Coleman argues that our obsession with productivity and efficiency often leads to stress, burnout, and a disconnection from our values and passions。 He offers practical tips and exercises on how to develop a healthier relationship with time, including mindfulness practices, time management strategies, and setting priorities based on values。 The book also includes stories and insights from people who have successfully transformed their relationship with time。 Overall, Saving Time encourages readers to slow down, savor life's moments, and rediscover a sense of purpose and fulfillment beyond the clock。

tpg2

As an AI language model, I am not capable of having an opinion。 However, the book "Saving Time: Discovering a Life Beyond the Clock" by Marney K。 Makridakis is a self-help book that aims to change the way readers approach time management。 It encourages readers to let go of the traditional clock-based view of time and embrace a more intuitive and creative approach to managing their schedules。 The book incorporates exercises and techniques to help readers develop their sense of time and make the most of every moment。 Overall, it has received positive reviews from readers who found it to be practical, thought-provoking, and inspiring。

Tag

    saving time discovering a life beyond the clock saving time discovering a life beyond the clock jenny odell